December 8th, 2018
0
I've heard that the figure of Zeus is based on a real person from my math teacher. I tried to fight him on it but he cited some book called Theagene by Heezyod or something (I haven't been able to find it on Google). Was he real???
December 8th, 2018
0
Here is a translation of the Theogony by Hesiod:
http://www.theoi.com/Text/HesiodTheogony.html
There isn't anything in there about Zeus being a mortal.
The belief your teacher was talking about is called Euhemerism. It was first recorded in the writings of Euhemerus,the 3rd century BC mythographer from Macedonia. He believed that many of the stories surrounding the gods stared out as the actions of mortals, but became exaggerated & mythologized over the many many retelling.
8
0
The god Zeús ultimately originates from the Proto-Indo-European sky god, Dyḗus Ph₂tḗr; this can be seen from the reconstructed Proto-Hellenic form Dzéus, which morphed into Zeús in Ancient Greek and was originally pronounced [zdeú̯s] and now came to be pronounced as [zefs] in Modern Greek. Ultimately neither are based on real people, so I don't know what your math teacher is talking about with that statement, especially since the Theogony by Hesiod never asserted that Zeús was human nor based on a human, but was always referred to as a god (as son of the Titan Rhea, daughter of the earth goddess Gaia).
I get the feeling that your math teacher simply tried to win the argument by citing a work that you didn't know about, since you wouldn't have known better and would therefore not have been able to argue back.
21
I believe there was a theory early on, well before the transliteration of Linear B, that the Greek pantheon originated from deified heroes of the Greek Dark Ages. The "Heroön" of Lefkandi was seen as such a cult place, and after all many of the mythical founders of Greek cities were worshipped in post-Geometric times, e.g. Cecrops in Athens. In a similar vein, it was argued, Zeus and others had been locally worshipped heroes before getting detached from their locality and becoming universal gods. We know today that the Greek gods go back much further in time so the theory doesn't hold water, but at a time the theory might have been seen as somewhat reasonable, especially for materialist historians. A similar phenomenon exists in Scandinavia were there's a tradition according to which the main gods Odin, Freyr and Thor are considered to have been mortal kings of Uppsala (coincidentally the three gods were worshipped there) in some distant past. IIRC Saxo Grammaticus speculates on it, and it might be a thouroughly Christian idea, but at least such thoughts have been voiced before. Finally, the idea that gods were ordinary men propelled by myth and legend to godhood is probably inherently appealing to atheists as it is by far the simplest method to dismiss religions altogether.
8